Does gear REALLY matter??

Yeah, gear matters.

Boiled down to it's barest essence, without it, you're playing air guitar. Literally.

Don't tell me gear doesn't matter. I'm not buying it.

 
I guess I should make a better response, which is that YES gear definitely does matter. Quality gear gets quality results. It doesn't have to be super fancy. But it needs to be well made. Guitars that have crappy action, bad resonance, and lame electronics  just don't work. I had a Yamaha RG2550E with the IBZ pickups, and no matter how hard I tried, I couldn't like the sound I got.

Then I got a Hamer Diablo. It was like Night and day. Those seymour duncan pickups killed it. I can see why now Ibanez has moved to using the Air Norton and Tone Zone on their RG Prestige series, and it's a good change.

Whether it's a high end boutique les paul type guitar, or a warmoth parts caster, if it's quality assembled with quality parts, you get good results.

Even though it is a modeller, the Yamaha THR10 is probably the best modeller I have played. The quality of modeled sound has REALLY gone up, to the point that if you are a gigging musician, and are your own roadie, you will me much better served by a modeller than super tube amp. You also can plug your modeller INTO your tube amp, if you really need to have the tubes. But in terms of flexibility, having a processor as opposed to a giant pedalboard is something I like.

Of course, nothing is quite like plugging into a 50 watt JMP Marshall half stack dimed with the two channels hard wired together. I FELT it. In my kidneys. I think I may have exploded some unsuspecting insects and small animals though.

 
It is easy for me to discern good gear from crappy gear, and there is no problem identifying great guitars.  The higher end stuff takes away excuses for not being able to get a great sound. 

Backing off of gear snob outlook, there are some really good mid priced Chinese guitars out there.  Many cheap basses have proven to be quite useful.  Amps seem to be the most touchy area as far as getting a good tone.  It seems that the better amps reveal sloppy technique more than the lower end amps.

 
While I totally understand what one means when they say tone is in the hands, I sometimes think that has more to do with only one aspect of tone (if it's really "tone" at all), otherwise why wouldn't EVH, or EJ, or any number of "tone chasers" simply settle on whatever is placed in front of them? Why is it we can distinguish between different eras of Eddie's tone? The fact that anyone can distinguish between different gear clearly means that a lot of tone is in the gear. 

So I'm just not really sure we're referring to tone when we talk about it being in the hands. Maybe it's actually just a certain feel, or style, or some abstract musical nuance that's hard to define. Something in the player's hands definitely brings a lot to the table, but is it "tone"? Maybe. Maybe not. Maybe we call it that in the absence of a better term.

 
While I totally understand what one means when they say tone is in the hands, I sometimes think that has more to do with only one aspect of tone (if it's really "tone" at all), otherwise why wouldn't EVH, or EJ, or any number of "tone chasers" simply settle on whatever is placed in front of them? Why is it we can distinguish between different eras of Eddie's tone? The fact that anyone can distinguish between different gear clearly means that a lot of tone is in the gear. 

So I'm just not really sure we're referring to tone when we talk about it being in the hands. Maybe it's actually just a certain feel, or style, or some abstract musical nuance that's hard to define. Something in the player's hands definitely brings a lot to the table, but is it "tone"? Maybe. Maybe not. Maybe we call it that in the absence of a better term.
+1 There are most definitely certain aspects of sound that can be and are influenced by the hands. However, the blanket statement that tone is in the hands is a lot of horse feathers. Tone, as defined by this: a musical or vocal sound with reference to its pitch, quality, and strength, can only be effected, to a degree, by one's fingers on the strings- pinch or natural harmonics, muted notes, pick attack etc. The rest HAS to come by way of gear. NO amount of digital (as in finger digits) manipulation can get the significant variations in tonal quality brought by gear. Try as I might, I cannot get a Martin acoustic to sound like a Strat run through an dimed Marshall. Period.

 
Gear materializes tone, so it's essential to connecting what's in your head and goes through your hands, to your ears.

My tone is me plus a decent guitar and a treble booster into anything that would break into overdrive when boosted. Then I got dozens of variations on the same pattern: a fixed wah and an overdrive instead of a treble booster; five different types of treble boosters; a Pignose preamp; a Tech21 Liverpool preamp; a Peavey Classic; an AC30; a guitar with P90's; a guitar with PAF's; a guitar with Burns Tri-sonics... There are of course nuances between all those configs, but they all satisfy my tastes.

But there's the key: it does matter when my gear sounds to my tastes. A lot! :)

 
Some good points here, and yeah gear matters.

  • Give me a Les Paul and a JCM800 and I'll make one sound
  • A Strat into a Pignose another
  • A Yairi classical another
  • A piano another
  • A trombone another
  • A bag of marbles yet another
There's only so much tone coming from the fingers. But I've come to the conclusion that if I have decent-quality electric guitar essentials - solid body guitar, cable, dirt/delay/modulation, amplification - I'll always end up sounding pretty much he same whether the logos on said gear are Huber and Klon and Dumble, or Cort and Boss and Crate. 

Obviously you should ENJOY the gear. Like I sold my Shishkov because the big pointy shape was weird to hold. But functionally it's not really that vital to be picky about gear, I think.

 
How you FEEL about the gear you are playing can affect your playing. I think that it's human nature. I play because of how it makes me feel. Both the music I am playing and the gear I am using can and will affect those feelings. 

 
If I go back and listen to different recordings I've done over the years, the tone is definitely different with various equipment. Maybe not drastic,but the difference is still there. At the same time, I do think that people have a tendency to dial in a similar tone based on personal taste regardless of equipment.  Another aspect is that when you really like your tone, guitar, etc. you are probably more into playing therefore that could translate to better playing whether perceived or real. It does seem that the better the player, the less variance between different gear. That being said I agree that the largest percentage come from the players hands. Gear of any type is never a substitution for putting in the practice time. In the long run, too much gear swapping, tone chasing can be more of a distraction for me personally.

 
I think it does and doesn't matter.  When you made that recording in your bedroom, you had a tone idea in your head.   If that idea hasn't changed vastly, you have upgraded your gear, but your tone goal was the same.  So, to me it's not a surprise that to you it's largely the same.  And it's you still playing the rig on top of that.

 
I'm to the point that I can be mostly happy just making a joyful noise.  It fun to buy and talk gear, but making a groovy, and mostly LOUD, noise makes me happy.  I'm grateful I learned how to play at an early age and my 1974-2016 gear timeline makes for terrific memories. I love the old gear and the new gear both.

 
Does this mean that careful programming of digital emulators is truly the equal of any imaginable rig? Maybe I should have just gotten a Kemper lunchbox thingie. 
I think probably but there will always be a bunch of people who do NOT roll their eyes when they hear shit like Eric Johnson taking apart the vibrato bridges on his Strats to remove the paint from the string block where it meets the bridge plate because it sounds better ( or other ridiculous claims ) that it doesn't matter. 

I read a few posts back someone say specific gear doesn't make them a better player but it can make them play better, I totally get that-playing through gear that doesn't sound good to you can be uninspiring. There is however a level of hand wringing OCD that to me is pointless.

 
There is no question that the answer is both the player and the gear make a contribution to the equation. Larry Carlton with his 335 has a different vibe and feel that his stuff with the Valley Arts instruments. I think iconic players always sound like themselves through any gear because they know what they are shooting for and how to get it. Most players try to dial in their tone with whatever rig they are using. Part of being a professional is making the most out of what you have.

ArnieZ

 
It would be silly to try to say I DO NOT like gear. FWIW, playing through something "better" inspires me to "try harder". At the same time, the PURSUIT of gear gets in the way of actually PLAYING.

This weekend, I used ONLY a "Junior" straight into an amp. Not even reverb. A "learning experience" to become a bit more creative using only the volume and tone knobs to "mix" with the other guitars (Strat and Tele). It seemed to work well, both to my ears and the guys I was playing with.

There are increasingly better solid state amps out there, at various price points, but I am still in love with the tube experience.

 
Tone is in the hands. Hands don't make your amp distorted or add a wah but the basic start is your touch. I'm so over gear, I crave skill and nuance
Tone is in YOUR BRAIN. Tone is your vision of how you want to sound. Your hands, your gear, all of those contribute to the final audible result. But yes, the hands are the first link in interpreting the mental vision with the audible outcome.

A good example of this was Joe Pass playing a Fender Jazzmaster. When he was in drug rehab, the only guitar in the facility was a Jazzmaster owned by Synanon itself. So Joe played it, and in doing so he managed to adjust the controls and his playing technique to get the sounds he wanted. At the end of his stay he recorded an album, "Sounds of Synanon" with the Jazzmaster. Still, the guitars he played when he got out were often a custom D'Aquisto, Gibson L5, or Gibson Super 400.



 
I think my "gearish-ness" is showing. Is the Jazz Master not playing a Jaguar (in that clip)? In some respects, that is even less of a traditional fit for jazz, what with the extra short scale and single cols pups. But it works and further shows his skills to get "his sound". Tremendous talent!

http://www.fender.com/guitars/jaguar/

 
Roy Lanham was an archtop player who adapted to electric when Fender offered an endorsement deal.  So, Roy just adjusted the knobs to get a tone consistent with what he had all along. 



 
Back
Top