I've played the first generation Blackjack 21 and though it was a great amp-very solid bass, and yes loud. Definitely not too bright, which I can't stand.
I had a friend with a Silverfaced Bassman head modified by Fuchs for the Dumble sound and that amp sounded great. Thing is, it is possible to get those tones with pedals and a good clean fender sounding amp.
It's much harder to duplicate an overdriven Marshall tone and feel.
Yes, a good tuned Fender with a Pedal sure you can get pretty darn close.
The Blackjack V1 and V2 are voiced differently, the V1 was shooting for the Trainwreck'ish thing and the V2 is the Fuchs Sound. I didn't buy the amp for the Dumble sound, I bought the amp because I listened to a bunch of youtube and then Andy was on a Podcast that I listened to. I liked what he had to say, I liked his thought process behind his amps and was all set to buy a NEW 4aces when I stumbled on a BlackJack21 Used for less money. Glad I purchased it but it was not love at first pluck. I had one issue that was resolved by a tech and Fuchs and then I did a few swaps of the speaker, adjusted the boost and now I orderd the TSR cable so I can velcro delay in the back. Ordered a 9volt box with an ON/Off switch that just plugs into the pedal so I can just kill the bat when not in use.
As for the "Marshall Tone" that tone that you hear has been clone man times over by pedals. Just look at how many Clones are out there, like any amplifiers tone it is the sum of the parts and the quality of the build. Not to mention the builder.
(Little Rant)
I pushed Egnaters hard a few years ago and they are great designes and Bruce is a great guy, BUT the amps were failing in the field, tons of complaints, I recieved horrible service from Egnater California as well as the repair shop in Chicago that I had to send it to. The warrenty repair ended up costing mea a chunck because I had to ship it and have it shipped back on my dime.
I ended up finding Budda, and damn that amp was fantastic and they are fantastic amps and Jeff will answer your emails and talked to you even though he doesn't own Budda anymore. Which led me to East Amplification, I had such a good positive transaction with Jeff that I sold the Budda and bought the East.
IMHO your going to have to spend more coin on an amp that is built, designed and cared for by builders that have their heart and soul in a product. No matter if you play at home or in front of 10,000 people they will answer your call or email and do what it takes to make you happy if your not a super demanding ego type.
Oh and holy smokes to think that we actually keep things that we buy instead of going to the next thing and the next thing. (GUILTY MYSELF) but i'm working on finding what it is that makes me happy and live with it. I'm going through this myself now, its freaking hard.