might be age too. I've been a dedicated player of 11s for 16 years straight. Used to be 11-52, but I'd "mellowed" down to 11-48.
Lately I've been putting in at least 2-3 hours a day, and my left hand is beginning to tingle unless I go through a slow and tedious warmup process. I do not want to have to go through wrist surgery, ever, to take even the tiniest risk of losing dexterity.
So like the OP, I've been beginning to wonder, why 11s? My wife has a Fender Hello Kitty guitar that she mostly likes to have as a decorative piece. It's strung 9-42. I played it the other day and was shocked at how much easier it is to play.
I used to think it was easier to get crazy low action without buzzing with 11s, and while that's true on my guitars, Joe Satriani plays with 9s and is very particular about having the lowest string action possible. He reportedly has a very, very light touch however.
I should also note that 11s are softer to play when they're locked at both ends with a Floyd system (shortening the string length to exactly 25.5"), and with low action. A guitar string 11-48 with high action, long headstock, and a tune-o-matic is much harder to play.
I may experiment with 9s. If my wrist gets any worse, it won't be a choice.