man.........there are sooooooooooooooooooooooo many variables here...and it all depends on who you ask b/c everything is relative. everything.
think; if identical pups are installed, you still have the location of the pups that are a factor...the bridge will ALWAYS get a diff sound, as will the neck pup....ALWAYS
IMO, that's THE REASON they did it in first place was to get a more 'even' sound between the pups.....like, lets say a 19' boat.....it will be subject to waaaaaaaaay diff circumstances if it was in a lake vs. being in the open ocean
location-location-location
.....and AFA 'joe blo's' *sound*, this too has many variables. most was recorded on TAPE..remember TAPE?....AND TAPE HAS IT'S OWN SET OF VARIABLES....it stretches and shrinks, even tho microscopic in many instances, it still does, and WILL affect the final sound
today w/ DIGITAL, all those variables are taken out of the equation
and in many ways, that 'sound' will never be gotten again b/c of the fact that everything today is recorded in such a sterile environment
back then, some stuff was recorded in varying *studios*...and i use the term lightly....who was drunk? or high? or whatever while taping...and do you think all studios were *hermetically* sealed like today. You had moisture, or humidity...some recorded in a hall, or basement, or truck, or trailer, ....w/ sound baffels, and w/o, w/ crappy mics of varying quality..then there's location, and bastard amps...and the list goes on...how about if the artist *just* changed his strings?...or *never* changed his strings?....then you got the whole *quality* of strings back then. You think that was the same?..FO REAL!....and, hey, how about the connections made w/ *leaded* solder compared to *unleaded* solder....hahahah....the list of variables goes on and on and on.....
trying to copy a *sound* from 1962, IMO, is like trying to find a needle in a haystack.,
......and a really, really, really BIG haystack, at that
well, enuf of my rant.
i'd just like to add that my 57 Classics in my 61 SG ri are prob THE BEST sounding HB pups i have
but know what i say to the newbies?...>>>> just go buy a goddam Squire and a modeling amp!