The Mcnaughts were fantastic guitars..I had a Vintage Double cut and a Vintage Single. The double that I had was heavy, and sounded kind of thin. I went through several pickup changes to try to fix this...but it just wasn't happening. The other guitar player in my band thought the same thing...so it wasn't just me. The second one was a Vintage Single cut..this one really bummed me out. When I fist played it unplugged, I was stunned...the thing rang like the proverbial bell. I couldn't wait to plug it in. When I was finally able to plug in and play at some volume....the thing was a dud. Again...I tried several different pickups, including Voodoos and Fralins, along with the stock Rios...no dice. I just couldn't get any of the thick, rich sounds that I would have expected from this model. It sounded more like a weak SG than a great single cut guitar. The woods and workmanship on the McNaughts were absolutely top notch. The flame maple binding on my single cut was unlike anything I have ever seen. But they just didn't have what I was looking for when they were played in a live situation at stage volume. The coil tapping was useless...too much of a volume drop. The Hubers are as good or better when it comes to the woods and workmanship. These things are about as flawless a guitar as you will find. I also like Niks choice of hardware better than McNaught. Nik uses a intonateable wrap around of his own design for a hardtail...and a trem of his own design that reminds me of the vintage PRS trems. But where Nik really has an advantage over McNaught is in the pickup department...The Hausell(sp?) pups that Nik uses are simply amazing. The humbuckers are warm and smooth without ever losing any clarity...and the split sounds are jaw dropping. This is the first guitar I have owned that I wouldn't even *think* of changing the pickups on. Everything about the Hubers is just amazing...the *only* problem that I have encountered is that it sometimes takes longer to get parts from Germany. I had a push-push pot go bad, and it took a little longer than I would have liked to get a replacement...thats not Niks fault and it is the price of doing business with someone in a different country.