EXACT thing happened to me! Reviews, Premier Guitar article... no guitar on the uber-hyped album (though he can play - saw him on a Crossroads with John Mayer). Fortunately, the 40-something denim-clad recipient of my CD was my wife (a fan of said over-produced "new country" crap).
This also happened (around the same time - I was trying to broaden my horizons - not a fan of country music) with an interview with Nels Cline about the new Wilco album. I listened to it once and mailed it to HFCer and Wilco fan, Aceldama - for FREE. Where was Nels on that album?
Though I believe Vai has the theory and concept of guitar like no one else and I love to watch him play live, I am amazed at how much of an effort it is to get through some of his music. I've always found Joe Satriani more listenable and blamed the difference on Vai's years with Zappa.
I excitedly recorded a friend's vinyl copy of Blow by Blow onto a cassette of my own (around '86), but when I listened to it, I found it tiresome. Great licks, amazing playing, but an effort to get through.
Was that not one of the greatest disappointments in a CD purchase? I find Carlton's contributed songs more listenable than Ritenour's, but to me the only song worth repeating on the entire CD is "Remembering J.P." (Carlton), that incidentally, didn't remind me of Joe Pass at all. Again, love seeing either of these guys play live, but the CD was as Johnny B said.
Oh my... no you didn't! Are you unaware of Metheny's complete and utter disdain for Kenny G? He has a real REAL problem with Kenny G and seems to share it any time he's given any sort of prompt. Just one e.g. Pray he doesn't read your comment.
Totally get Hendrix, but I was a fan way before I played guitar - began in high school with second-hand bootlegs on eight-track given to me by an old stoner type I used to work with. I could listen to him all day, even now. Edited to add: Hendrix, not the aforementioned old stoner benefactor.