Do people like the way this forum works

[hikarateboy]

As you will notice I converted Ask HFC Experts to a true question and answer forum where the best answers can be voted up.  Is it working for you and do you like it?

[it's me HHB]

Seriously confusing, please go back, were getting old lol

[kizanski]

On February 11, 2016 at 1:53 PM, kizanski said:

Not feeling this voting thing.

It changes the order of the posts so you can't tell who's replying to who.

 

On February 11, 2016 at 2:06 PM, tommy p said:

That was my concern too, but there's a "sort by" option at the top so you can go by date or answer rating.  Not too shabby.

Not interested in "sorting" something which should already be in order.

Thumbs down.

[hikarateboy]

So,  You can still sort by date which makes it just like the old way and no longer confusing.  Is that enough or do we need to go back to the old way? Not sure if that can be set as default. 

[cynic]

15 minutes ago, hikarateboy said:

Is that enough or do we need to go back to the old way?

Old way please

 

New way:

1) click the thread

2) scroll to the top

3) click the button to resort

4) scroll to the bottom of the thread

5) click to the last page

6) scroll down to see most recent posts

 

Old way:

1) click the thread

[kizanski]

Old way, please. 

Failed experiment. 

Pull the plug. 

Abort. 

 

[Steve Haynie]

Just seeing a lot of people like a reply in Ask The Experts was a good way to know if the reply had good information.

[ARM OF HAMER]

                               God knows I'm no expert...............least of all here and while I appreciate all you do to keep us all up and running I DO prefer the old format...............it was just better that way.

[Boomerang~Junkie]

A little confusing and perhaps the ghost of Rube Golberg going on here.

Please, please go back to square avatars - the round ones trim too much off the images which are square to begin with.

I do truly appreciate your efforts though - thank you.

[Caddie]

Uh , to be blunt, no I don't like it.  I thought it was just me being slow on the learning curve or stuck in the rut of my old ways.  Well sorry guys, I know you were trying to do your best and put a lot of effort into it and we sincerely thank you for your management of our little HFC.  But gents, this upgrade is a downer.  Sorry.  Again no reflection on you, you work on our HFC for free!  So that we can crack-wise, maybe sell or buy something, get some help for all things guitar and then some.  and we thank you.....

Cheers!

caddie

[mathman]

Does the voting have to resort the posts?  I guess the option to like the post is. All we need.