If you say so, that's enough proof for me.
The second was not a "point", it was a question (marked as such ). I obviously understand a bidding process. I thought Chris was talking about offers off-Ebay, where I just found surprising that someone would offer more than a price at which the seller would be happy, on a non-auction process.
I was talking about BOTH, actually. I am aware of one "off-eBay" sale where the buyer paid more than a seller's original asking price because he wanted to make sure he got the deal. There had apparently been interest in the guitar, but nobody had pulled the trigger (over a 24-hour or less period). The ultimate buyer chimed in with a deal above asking price and the deal was sealed. If that person chooses to confirm here, that is entirely up to them, but this is not an uncommon thing - I've seen it happen many times over the last 20-25 years with vintage instruments (and DC Metro Real Estate!).