gtrdaddy Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 I just don't know what to think. For a minute she seemed, well sorta, maybe hot... then she opened her mouth.
Carl.B Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 Coming from the Achy Breaky Heart gene pool my hopes were never to high.
gtrdaddy Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 1 minute ago, Carl.B said: Coming from the Achy Breaky Heart gene pool my hopes were never to high. Well at least her daddy could sing...
Ting Ho Dung Posted October 14, 2021 Author Posted October 14, 2021 37 minutes ago, gtrdaddy said: I just don't know what to think. For a minute she seemed, well sorta, maybe hot... then she opened her mouth. She does seem "sorta". But then it's kinda like looking at your own shit in the toilet.
Menehune Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 As obnoxious as Miley Cyrus has become, her voice is excellent in its natural timbre and volume - the light fluttering tremolo she developed is really pretty in her ballads. Certainly not on display here, though - although she tries to make Black Dog her own, she succeeds only in fucking it up. Robert Plant was 22, 23 when he recorded Black Dog, using an admittedly raw voice and whose range would quickly decrease with time. Cyrus sang this version at Glastonbury in 2019, which would make her 26 at this performance. I would expect a female singer of that age, trained in rock singing, to hit that E5 with ease - which tells me she either hasn't trained to belt, or doesn't warm up. Either way, she sucks. Cyrus's calculated theatrical path to stardom is well-traveled. Witness Ozzy Osbourne, Lady Gaga, SIA, Bowie. Hell, even The Tubes, Be Bop Deluxe, and early Genesis. But all those musicians and bands weren't lazy in refining their musical craft. Cyrus has become lazy, which is a shame.
cynic Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 With all the fuck you money she’s stashed away I doubt it’s lazy as much as it’s not giving a fuck. I thinks she’s just discovered other things she cares more about than pretending to be a serious musician.
Dutchman Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 Yep, She suck's singing that!!! The band sounded good!!
Travis Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 But, at least you can see her nipples thru her top. That’s gotta account for something, right…?
mirrorimij Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 Maybe this one will offset the effects of the first video.
Ting Ho Dung Posted October 14, 2021 Author Posted October 14, 2021 1 hour ago, Dutchman said: Yep, She suck's singing that!!! The band sounded good!! You gotta wonder if those guys hate that gig.
Ting Ho Dung Posted October 14, 2021 Author Posted October 14, 2021 39 minutes ago, Travis said: But, at least you can see her nipples thru her top. That’s gotta account for something, right…? Yep, click bait for sure. Got me to watch it full screen twice. Maybe a third with the sound off.
Ting Ho Dung Posted October 14, 2021 Author Posted October 14, 2021 31 minutes ago, mirrorimij said: Maybe this one will offset the effects of the first video. Meh, you couldn't see her nipples.
hamerhead Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 58 minutes ago, Travis said: But, at least you can see her nipples thru her top. That’s gotta account for something, right…? Goddammit Travis. You made me go back and watch and I didn't hit the mute button fast enough. Now I need some peroxide for my ears.
Disturber Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 I dunno... but I think you are slagging her off to lightly. Girls got pipes. She sounds dirty. I get a Lucinda Williams vibe from this young chick. I give it thumbs up. So in this thread I read that she's rich, does not care or give a fuck. We'll that's like young, loud and snotty then. Punk all the way. I say go girl, not many women doing this today. Keep it up and shove that dirty finger of yours up the faces of old farts like us. We have it coming. Lazy sods sitting behind our keyboards in our offices giving you critisism. While you are up there doing what we wish we could have done with our lives all along. (haha, let the flaming begin).
kizanski Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 27 minutes ago, Disturber said: I dunno... but I think you are slagging her off to lightly. Girls got pipes. She sounds dirty. I get a Lucinda Williams vibe from this young chick. I give it thumbs up. So in this thread I read that she's rich, does not care or give a fuck. We'll that's like young, loud and snotty then. Punk all the way. I say go girl, not many women doing this today. Miley, Beyonce, Christina Aguilera, Fergie... These women all have amazing voices. Not good. Not great. Amazing. It's easy to pick the low hangin fruit and poke fun at them, since they're in your face non-stop (well, not Xtina and Fergie as much anymore) and their music might not be your thing, but don't let your bias color what you're hearing.
MCChris Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 Everyone should also keep in mind that the OP is a Hellyeah fan.
kizanski Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 3 minutes ago, MCChris said: Everyone should also keep in mind that the OP is a Hellyeah fan. Right. The constant barrage of dogshit recommendations tends to undercut the criticism of someone with actual talent.
gtrdaddy Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 3 hours ago, mirrorimij said: Maybe this one will offset the effects of the first video. I dunno... It's certainly better than the performance in the OP, but who would rather listen to this than Dolly's version? 48 minutes ago, kizanski said: Miley, Beyonce, Christina Aguilera, Fergie... These women all have amazing voices. Not good. Not great. Amazing. I'm with you on all but Miley. Hell, I wish I could sing as well as her, and certainly can't. But as much a better singer she is than I, I still don't think she's got superstar pipes. Enough to thrill children perhaps, but to me her voice is annoying. Perhaps I'm just more deaf than I realize; perhaps I'm not deaf enough
tbonesullivan Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 It was ok, but she's not a 20 something dude rocking falsetto and shredding his vocal cords. She also really has an Alto or Contralto singing voice, and her speaking voice has always lower and rougher than typical for pop stars, even when she was still doing Hannah Montana. She may have a higher range but may not want to go into her falsetto range, as it may lack the power of her regular range. Unless she wants to destroy her vocal cords like Steven Tyler, Robert Plant, Brian Johnson, and any number of other Rock N Roll screamers.
hamerhead Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 1 hour ago, gtrdaddy said: I dunno... It's certainly better than the performance in the OP, but who would rather listen to this than Dolly's version? Nice choice, Jamie. Of all songs in the history of recorded music, that one makes my personal top-10 of nails-on-a-chalkboard awful, regardless of the voice behind it.
Carl.B Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 2 hours ago, kizanski said: Miley, Beyonce, Christina Aguilera, Fergie... These women all have amazing voices. Not good. Not great. Amazing. It's easy to pick the low hangin fruit and poke fun at them, since they're in your face non-stop (well, not Xtina and Fergie as much anymore) and their music might not be your thing, but don't let your bias color what you're hearing. I will take 71 year old Ann Wilson version over Miley's any day.
kizanski Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 Just now, Carl.B said: I will take 71 year old Ann Wilson version over Miley's any day. It's not an either/or. You don't really have to choose.
gtrdaddy Posted October 14, 2021 Posted October 14, 2021 1 hour ago, tbonesullivan said: her speaking voice has always lower and rougher than typical for pop stars, even when she was still doing Hannah Montana. Wouldn't know anything about that... ...creeping me out
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.